Which Martial Art Should I Learn?
This is a question I get asked a lot. Well being a Systema instructor I’m a little biased to begin with but the truth is that there are many styles and disciplines to choose from.
In the end it comes down to personal preference in regards to what you want get out of your training along with your personality and body type. You will be more likely to stick to training in something that you are better suited to both physically and mentally rather than just picking a style because someone told you to do it.
I have come up with this short questionnaire to help you determine which martial may be the right fit for you. Of course there are many more martial arts than I have listed here but it will give you a good starting point.
There are 10 multiple choice questions that should try and answer honestly to best find your match. Some questions may have several answers that you agree with, or none that you agree with, but you should try to answer the best possible one. At the end of the test your result will appear with a brief description of the art. Please enjoy and if you like the quiz please share the results with your friends.
For those of you who want more information on each of the styles listed in this quiz feel free to read the information below.
MUAY THAI
Hailing from Thailand, Muay Thai is a style of kickboxing known as the “art of eight limbs” as it is characterised by the combined use of fists, elbows, knees, and shins as well as a stand-up form of grappling called clinching.
Many MMA fighters use Muay Thai as a basis for their striking. Training involves drilling combinations on pads as well as sparring. Flexibility especially in the legs can be a great help when first starting training.
While this is a fantastic martial art for striking, competition and physical fitness, it does not focus at all on ground fighting or weapons training which limits its applicability in a self defence scenario.
Where have you seen it: The Ong Bak movies starring Tony Jaa and Kickboxer starring Jean Claude Van Damme.
What to expect: Techniques are first drilled on Thai pads and heavy bags and then practiced with a partner. Strikes are performed with the hands, elbows, shins and knees. Once you’ve learnt how to properly throw strikes you will progress to sparring. Standing clinch work is an excellent test of your core strength and endurance.
Is it for you? If you are looking for a competitive art with plenty of contact then this is a good place to start. A lot of MMA fighters use Muay Thai as a base for their striking game. Due to its popularity it shouldn’t be too difficult to find a good school within your area.
WING CHUN
A Southern Chinese martial art that rose to popularity as it was the original martial art that Bruce Lee first studied.
While there are low kicks in Wing Chun most attacks consist of rapid punches which are thrown while moving forward into the opponent. The focus is on controlling the opponents’’ centre line by redirecting their strikes and maintaining a powerful structure while fighting.
While there is an element of weapons training (staff and butterfly swords) there is minimal ground fighting and grappling.
Where have you seen it: On the big screen in the Ip Man moves series starring Donnie Yen.
What to expect: Wing Chun’s foundation principle is to control the centre line. The basic stance, which is different to many other martial arts, requires you to stand facing forward with knees bent and feet point slightly outward and can leave you quite sore in the beginning. Punches are performed in rapid succession while moving forward into your opponent. Kicks are often thrown below waist height. There are 6 Wing Chun forms that help teach you body positioning, balance and hand/eye coordination.
Is it for you? It is a close-combat system with punching and trapping preferred over long range kicks. Initially the blocks can be particularly hard on the forearms for the first few months but it’s a great martial art to improve your reflexes, balance and coordination.
TAI CHI
An internal Chines martial art which was once practiced for self defence, but is now more commonly practiced for its health benefits and mediation.
It involves a series of movements performed in a slow, focused manner and accompanied by deep breathing which means anyone regardless of age or level of fitness can practice and benefit from Tai Chi.
While being great for overall health and longevity Tai Chi is limited as a form of self defence and has no grappling or wrestling techniques.
Where have you seen it: You can often find early morning session in your local park. On the big screen you can see it in Jet Li’s Tai Chi Master.
What to expect: Tai Chi training is made up of 3 parts. Class begins with warm up exercises which are light stretches and postures aimed at relaxing the body and preparing it for the upcoming class. The second phase is form practice in which the basic movements of Tai Chi are practiced in a flowing sequence. The final part is Qigong which are meditative movements aimed at coordinating the body, mind and breath.
Is it for you? Tai Chi is a gentle way to improve your overall health. Some of the health benefits associated with its practice includes improved circulation, reduced pain and stress and a general feeling of overall wellness. People suffering from arthritis, fibromyalgia and Parkinson ’s disease have found benefit from practicing Tai Chi.
JUDO
Developed in Japan in the late 1800s, Judo concentrates on throws, chokes or submissions and has developed to become a modern combat Olympic sport. Its techniques focus on using leverage and momentum to minimise the need to strength and power.
While strikes are a part of Judo they are only thrown during kata or pre-arranged forms and are not allowed in competition or free practice.
While considered a sport there are many elements that you can apply in a self defence scenario but it limited in regards to weapons training.
Where have you seen it: Judo has been an Olympic sport since the Tokyo games in 1964.
What to expect: You can expect to get thrown a lot so learning how to fall correctly is essential in the beginning. While there is no striking there is plenty of contact. Expect to get a full body workout. Finger injuries are common due to the large amount of griping and throwing. Class environment is more traditional then say BJJ having to bow and line up according to rank much like in karate or aikido. Classes are commonly divided into three parts: warm-up, drilling and free sparring (randori). Warm-ups often consist of stretching and basic movements that you often use in class including lots of break falls. The drilling component involves practicing particular techniques shown by the instructor. Techniques include throws, locks, chokes and escapes. The final part is randori where you get the opportunity to try and submit a resistive opponent by using the techniques you have learnt.
Is it for you? Judo is a great blend of a traditional martial art mixed with a modern sportive element. If you like the idea of training in an art which focuses on throwing with some ground work thrown in for good measure then judo is perfect for you. You will get a great workout with plenty of impact and there is even the chance to compete at the Olympic Games.
BRAZILIAN JIU JITSU
A ground based grappling art that was developed from Judo in the early 1900’s in Brazil. It is founded on the concept that through an understanding of technique and leverage a smaller person is able to overcome a larger opponent.
Sparring, which is often referred to as rolling, is where two practitioners are wrestling on the ground trying to submit their opponent via chokes and joint locks. It is extremely fatiguing on just about every muscle in the body and helps develop excellent cardio fitness.
While considered both a sport and martial art it’s self defence applications are somewhat limited to a single opponent and has little or no focus on weapon usage or defence.
Where have you seen it: If you have watched any UFC event then you will have seen some BJJ. Some major movies with fight scenes that feature BJJ include Flash Point with Donnie Yen and a triangle choke by Tom Cruise in Oblivion.
What to expect: Classes are commonly divided into three parts: warm-up, drilling and free sparring. Warm-ups often consist of stretching and basic movements that you often use in class including break falls. The drilling component involves practicing particular techniques shown by the instructor. Techniques include chokes, joint locks and escapes. The final part is sparring where you get the opportunity to try and submit a resistive opponent by using the techniques you have learnt.
Is it for you? If you want to punch and kick or don’t like the idea of rolling around with another sweaty person then BJJ is not for you. But if you are looking for a challenging competitive sport that will work your whole body then this might be the art for you.
MIXED MARTIAL ARTS
As the name implies mixed martial arts is not a single martial art but a kind of fighting style popularised by the Ultimate Fighting Championship and is a mixture of stand-up striking and grappling. Muay Thai and boxing are common for striking and wrestling and Brazilian jiu jitsu are common for the grappling aspect.
Training is quite intense which will help you develop excellent cardiovascular fitness and sparring often involves some level of contact.
As a sport based martial art focused on competitive fighting and as such it’s self defence applications are somewhat limited to single opponents with no focus on weapon usage or defence.
Where have you seen it: Thanks to the popularity of the Ultimate Fighting Championship (UFC) MMA has become one of the fastest growing sports in the world with the likes of Connor McGregor and Georges St- Pierre becoming house hold names. The movie Warrior starring Tom Hardy is a recent big screen example.
What to expect: A high intensity workout since you will have to cover a lot of material. Most programs will consist of several elements – Boxing and Muay Thai for striking, wrestling for grappling and BJJ for submissions. Training will combine drilling combinations on pads, along with partner work and sparring. Contact will be very common and you can expect to leave sore and exhausted.
Is it for you? Because there is so much to learn in each of the major disciplines involved in MMA it requires a much bigger time commitment than other martial arts. It is great if you are interested in competition and as its popularity increases it’s becoming easier to find good schools in your local area. If you don’t like the idea of contact when training then this is defiantly not the art for you.
FILIPINO MARTIAL ARTS
Filipino Martial Arts (FMA) is also known by the names Eskrima, Kali or Arnis and includes both empty-hand and weapons training incorporating techniques from both Eastern and Western martial traditions.
Combining empty-handed techniques with the ability to wield sticks, swords and knives, the real skill to this art lies in the ability to quickly interchange between the two, armed and unarmed.
One limitation is the little emphasis placed on grappling and wrestling.
Where have you seen it: The classic Enter the Dragon with Bruce Lee along with the Bourne trilogy movies. For fun the legendary Dan Inosanto makes a cameo appearance on Big Stan.
What to expect: Most FMA training consists of training with weapons such as sticks and knives but most movements translate well into empty hand self defence techniques. Training will help improve your hand and reaction speed, awareness and hand-eye coordination. Classes will focus on how to strike along with blocks and counters. Basic triangular footwork patterns will also be taught.
Is it for you? If you like the idea of learning a martial art that places a heavy emphasis on weapons training first then FMA is perfect for you. These skills can easily be transferred to empty hand work and both are valuable in self defence scenarios.
KRAV MAGA
Was developed by the Israeli Defence Force to be used in real-life combat situations. Its focus was to take techniques from a number of other styles and make them teachable to military solders. The main objective is to overwhelm the attacker with force while targeting vulnerable areas of the body.
There is no sportive element as most of the techniques employed are banned from combat sports but training includes sparring and scenario drills as well as dealing with attacks using various weapons.
Where have you seen it: Elements of Krav Maga are seen in movies such as Collateral with Tom Cruise or Skyfall with Daniel Craig.
What to expect: Krav Maga is known for its high intensity workouts. Classes begin with a warm up to prepare the body for the upcoming training. This is then followed by lots of drilling where you will be taught how to strike, kick and escape from various holds. Techniques such as groin strikes and eye pokes are all part of the game unlike many sports based martial arts. Expect lots of impact and you will be expected to purchase protective gear such as groin guard, mouth guard and headgear for sparring.
Is it for you? If you are looking for a high intensity workout and learn how to kick ass at the same time then Krav Maga is a great art to consider. Due to the intensity of training you will get a little battered and bruised with the odd injury here and there. The focus on training will be on self defence don’t expect to find any Krav Maga competitions to participate in.
SYSTEMA
A Russian martial art that was originally devised from Cossack fighting and then modified to be used by Russian Special Forces. It combines elements of stand-up striking, grappling, and weapons training with an emphasis placed on natural body movements that can be learned quickly. The goal of training was always to improve body movement, increase health and general well-being, while mastering the art of fighting.
Systema students train for real-life combat situations and the potential to defend against multiple armed opponents. While sparring is a part of the training there is no sportive element.
Where have you seen it: Systema instructor Kevin Secours did all the motion capture in the game Splinter Cell Blacklist.
What to expect: A typical systema class begins with a warm up which focuses on breath work and movement to prepare you for the upcoming training. Unlike most martial arts, Systema’s focus is not on memorising techniques but rather understanding the principles behind the techniques so that they can be applied in any situation. Avoidance, deflection and evasion are prioritised over hard blocking minimising the strain placed on the body’s joints and ligaments. Strikes are taught to be dissipated through movement and correct breathing rather than just to grin and bear it. Training will cover aspects of striking and kicking, grappling and wrestling along with weapons defence and dealing with multiple attackers.
Is it for you? With a good mix of high intensity training and restorative health work to help reduce fear and tension Systema is a practical way to learn to self defence while improving your overall health and fitness. The most challenging part will be to find a school with in your local area.
TAEKWONDO
A Korean martial art which is part of the Olympic games and has more participants than any other art. Its main focus is on stand up fighting with a heavy emphasis placed on kicking techniques.
Training is made up of drilling and sparring which help build up your cardiovascular fitness and flexibility.
Due to the popularity of the sporting element training is often focused on competition rather than street self defence. There is also an absence of grappling or wrestling techniques.
Where have you seen it: First introduced into the Olympics at the 1988 Seoul games.
What to expect: You can expect a lot of stretching, kicking drills and sparring in a Taekwondo class. You may be even shown how to break a board or two. Taekwondo places a lot of emphasis on kicking and cardiovascular fitness to expect your legs to be sore and tried in the beginning.
Is it for you? Taekwondo is the most practiced martial art in the world so finding a good school in your area shouldn’t be too hard. If you want an art with plenty of competition and a heavy focus on kicking then this is the style for you.
KARATE
First developed in Okinawa it is predominantly a striking art using punching, kicking, knee and elbow strikes along with open- hand techniques. The name Karate can be translated to “the way of the empty hand” with the ultimate aim of perfecting the characters of its practitioners.
There are many styles and associations exist, with the some of the major associations styles being Shotokan, Wado Ryu, Goju Ryu, Kyokushinkai and Shito Ryu.
It is both a martial art and sport with different emphasis placed on each element according to the individual school. There is an absence of grappling or wresting techniques.
Where have you seen it: How can you go past Daniel san in the Karate Kid movies? Wax on wax off.
What to expect: Karate is your typical traditional martial art aimed at teaching respect, focus and humility. As a show of respect you will be expected to bow upon entering and leaving the dojo and training area along with your training partner during class. There are 3 main aspects of Karate training kihon, kata and kumite. Kihon refers to the foundational techniques that are taught and includes stances, punches, kicks and blocks. Kata or forms are choreographed movement patterns used as a way to practice and memorise techniques. Kumite refers to the various form of sparring. Karate will make its Olympic debut in the 2020 Tokyo games.
Is it for you? If you are looking for a solid traditional martial art with the possibility of competing in tournaments then Karate is a perfect fit for you. Due to its popularity it is also easy for most people to find a good quality dojo in their area.
AIKIDO
A Japanese martial art created by Morihei Ueshiba and represents a culmination of his studies of various styles of Jujitsu, sword and spear arts. The name is often translated to the way of harmony
Aikido uses twisting and throwing techniques to turn an attacker’s strength and momentum against them. Performed well it requires very little physical energy.
There are no competitive tournaments in Aikido and its practitioners tend to place a greater focus on spirituality/philosophy rather than self defence.
Where have you seen it: All of Steven Seagal’s movies.
What to expect: As a traditional Japanese martial art, as a show of respect, you will be expected to bow upon entering and leaving the dojo and training area along with your training partner during class. A typical class will begin with a warm up designed not only to prepare the body for the upcoming training but to gain an understanding of correct body structure, alignment and weight distribution. As aikido involves a number of throws it is imperative at you first learn to fall correctly. Atemi or strikes, are often used to unbalance your opponent to enable you to enter and either throw, hold or pin the attacker. Weapons training consists of the bokken (wooden sword), jo (staff) and tanto (wooden knife). Students also learn to deal with attacks from a traditional Japanese kneeling position.
Is it for you? If you like the idea of learning a tradition martial art which teaches how to throw and pin along with traditional Japanese weapons than aikido is a good fit for you. If you have any knee issues then you may have some difficulty in performing the shikko or Japanese knee walking. Due to its popularity it shouldn’t be too hard to find a good dojo near you.